A tale of four swamps

Contents of this page

 
 
The aim of this page is to compare four similar public reserves in or near Mandurah, all based on seasonally variable swamps, all beautiful and popular with the local people. Three of these are are suffering badly from weed invasion while the forth is relatively free of the two most invasive of the local weeds.

I've made a project of keeping some level of control over the weeds in and adjacent to the parks and reserves near my home. This includes a seasonal swamp in the Len Howard Conservation Park. I've called the area the Big Seasonal Paperbark Swamp (BSPS), for lack of any formal name.

The two most common, conspicuous and invasive weeds in the reserves discussed on this page are fleabane (several species of the genus Erigeron) and false onion weed (Trachyandra divaricata), otherwise known as strap weed or simply onion weed. Other weeds that I am working at removing from the BSPS include Centaurea melitensis, Maltese cockspur; Solanum linnaeanum, devil's apple and Solanum nigrum, Black nightshade.

This page was started 2023/12/12
Contact: David K. Clarke – ©


A part of the northern end of the BSPS reserve
Kangaroos
Most of the Big Paperbark Swamp Mob. There are at least 24 kangaroos in the photographed area. They all live in the vicinity of the reserve, although it's not uncommon to see them grazing nearby lawns.

This reserve has been badly infested by fleabane and false onion weed in the past.

Photo iPhone 11 Pro, telephoto lens, 6mm, 2022/07/26





Introduction

In what follows I've provided photos of out of control weeds in the three swamp reserves that no one seems to care about first, the reserve that I try to look after is shown last. (The three neglected reserves are too far from my home for me to look after, and my time has been fully committed closer to home.)

People value, or at least should value, their public parks. I see many people whenever I'm walking, riding or working in one of them. I'm sure that many people get great enjoyment and relaxation from their parks. The fact that there seems to be very few who are willing to look after them has long been a mystery to me.

All the parks and reserves I've written about on this page are in or near Mandurah, a city of 100,000 people about 70km south of Perth, the capital and largest city in the state of Western Australia. There are, of course, many people who put in voluntary time contributing to looking after the things and places that we love and value, but I do wonder why there are so few who are willing to work at controlling weeds in parks and other public places?

It is likely that some people are reluctant to start because they are not sure which plants are weeds and which are natives. That is understandable, but a bit of time spent in study and identification would soon fix it.

Anyone who wanted to try would not necessarily take on a whole park, they could easily start in one section of one of the parks. Do as much as they wanted and a section at a time. Should anyone want help getting started, they could contact me; my email address is on the About Me page.



Tamworth Hill Swamp Reserve, Baldivis

 
Fleabane in Tamworth Hill Swamp Reserve
Fleabane in Tamworth Hill Swamp
 
Presumably Tamworth Hill in the background, the swamp in the middle distance with numerous fleabane plants in the foreground
Tamworth Hill, the swamp in the foreground
Photo iPhone 11 Pro, telephoto lens, 6mm fl, 2023/12/12
This reserve is at Baldivis about 25 kilometres to the north of Mandurah. It's a large reserve, of about 67 hectares, and consists of native bush surrounding a swamp that seems to largely be covered with reeds.

Tamworth Hill Swamp Reserve was the first place in the Mandurah region where I came across fleabane that was thoroughly out of control (photo on the right, taken 2022/03/02).

The fleabane is by no means throughout the reserve, but there are many places near the walking trail where it is in large numbers. It struck me at the time that it would be disastrous to the Len Howard Conservation Park, near my home in Erskine, if fleabane was to colonise it in a similar way.

I saw plants around three metres tall in the Tamworth Hill Swamp Reserve. Apparently conditions there are ideal for the growth of the weed; conditions in parts of the Len Howard Reserve would be much the same.

I visited Tamworth Hill Swamp Reserve again in mid December 2023 and the situation had not improved. I saw many areas that fleabane had invaded, the second photo is just one such.



Marlee Reserve, Mandurah

 
Fleabane in Marlee Reserve (Mandurah north)
Fleabane in Marlee Reserve
This infestation of fleabane was in the western section of Marlee Reserve.
Photographed 2022/11/15, iPhone 11 Pro, standard lens
Marlee Reserve covers about 25 hectares. It has what seems to be a permanent swamp largely covered with paperbark (Melaleuca) trees in its centre.

Like all the parks I've covered on this page it is attractive and popular with walkers and joggers.

It is also home to one of the Mandurah giants.

 
Onion weed in Marlee reserve
Onion weed in Marlee reserve
While the onion weed was not conspicuous at the time of year that this photo was taken (December, 2023) it was easily seen and in fairly high numbers between the main car park and the giant.

Both fleabane and onion weed readily colonise bare or disturbed areas. Onion weed has become established near one of the other of the Mandurah giants.

Fleabane plants can generally but pulled out, false onion weed needs to be dug out to get the bulbuls out of the ground.

Click on the image to see it in higher definition.



Black Swan Lake Reserve, Lakelands

 
Black Swan Lake Reserve, Lakelands (Mandurah north)
Fleabane in Black Swan Lake Reserve
The tall grey plants are fleabane. The photo was taken on the western side of the reserve.
Photo 2023/06/21, iPone 11 Pro, telephoto lens, 6mm focal length
This very attractive reserve surrounds Black Swan Lake and covers about 39 hectares. It is a popular place for walkers and joggers.

The photo shows many tall fleabane plants as they were in winter, after they had gone to seed and dried.

Fleabane plants are scattered around the reserve in a number of places.

As with any of the weeds, it would be quite possible to gradually eradicate them, one section of the park at a time.

Scotch thistles are also fairly common. (In Bowman Park, SA I have found spraying Scotch thistles with glyphosate the best way of controlling them, it is difficult to remove enough of the root by hoeing them out.)

 
Fleabane at Black Swan Lake Reserve
Another photo of fleabane at Black Swan Lake Reserve, this was taken in the northeast part of the reserve. It was summer so the plants were growing vigorously.

Photo iPhone 11 Pro, standard lens, fl 4.25mm, 2024/01/09

An example of how to provide a perfect seedbed for the establishment of weeds
This one in Black Swan Lake Reserve, Lakelands

 
A perfect seedbed for weed establishment
A perfect seedbed for weed establishment has been provided here beside the path.

Fleabane seeds move about with the wind. They would settle in placed like this cleared strip and find a perfect place to germinate without any competition.

The photo below shows the likely result that I'd expect a year or two later.

Photo iPhone 11 Pro, standard lens, fl 4.25mm, 2024/01/09

 
Fleabane taking advantage of the seedbed provided
Fleabane taking full advantage of the seedbed provided by whoever cleared the pre-existing vegetation from the side of the path.

This area must have been cleared a year or so earlier than in the photo above, the fleabane has become well established.

Photo iPhone 11 Pro, standard lens, fl 4.25mm, 2024/01/09



The Big Seasonal Paperbark Swamp (BSPS) reserve, Mandurah

 
Fleabane outbreak
Photo, iPhone 11 Pro, standard lens, 2023/12/09
The BSPS reserve seems to be a part of the Len Howard Conservation Park, its area is around 19 hectares.

The outbreak in the photo on the right was far enough from the path to be easily passed by without seeing, it was among the trees in the northeast part of the BSPS.

This gives a hint of how bad fleabane could be in the LHCP if it was unchecked but as I'm pulling or digging out all those that I can find as soon as I find them fleabane (and onion weed) is becoming scarce in the BSPS.

In fact I seem to be making good progress on removing both of these major weeds from the area within a kilometre or two of my home (December 2023). I have pulled or dug out tens of thousands of plants of each of the two species. There is a record of my work on fleabane and onion weed on another page.

 
Dune onion weed in the northern end of BSPS
before it was dug out
Photo iPhone 11 Pro, standard lens, 2022/08/18
The photo on the right shows dune onion weed plants at the northern end of the BSPS that were going to seed at the time, 2022/08/18. The infestations were thickest on the northern and northeastern parts of the reserve, but there were also quite a few scattered plants in the southern part.

I believe that I have, with some help from Council, largely controlled this invasive weed in the BSPS reserve.

Two differences between the reserves

In regard to the common and invasive weed, fleabane, there are two differences between the BSPS and the other swamp reserves discussed on this page.
  1. In the BSPS reserve you will see very few fleabane plants while you will see them in large numbers in the the other reserves, and
  2. In the BSPS reserve fleabane has set very little seed over the past two years, while in the other reserves there would be a lot of fleabane seed ready to germinate next year.
Much the same applies to onion weed (it does not seem to be present in Tamworth Hill Swamp reserve and possibly not in Black Swan Lake reserve).


The BSPS; a lovely public place, too beautiful to allow it to be taken over by weeds
Big seasonally paperbark swamp

Erskine had a wet winter, at least up to the time of photographing this, 2022/07/24. By my records there had been 129mm of rain in May, 148mm in June and 109mm up to 24th of July. Consequently the Big Seasonal Paperbark Swamp was full and overflowing into the main estuary pool.

 
There is a concrete path right around the outside of the BSPS and very few walkers, joggers or cyclists leave the path.

Consequently few people see the full beauty of the swamp, as I do when I walk through it looking for weeds. One of the bonuses of looking after the park.

This section of the BSPS is flooded each winter.


End word

If I, at the time of writing a 78 year-old, can control these two invasive species in the BSPS (and in other public places near my home) surely there are a few others who could do the same in the other reserves, and in parks and reserves everywhere.

We can all, and should all, contribute to looking after our shared public areas.

A motto I use is: If I see something that needs fixing and I'm capable of fixing it and I don't fix it, why should anyone else?





References and related pages

On this site...

Looking after what is good

Ethics

Climate change; a threat far greater than invasive weeds in local swamps

Environment; it's what we all share and we should all help look after it

Do something, don't just walk by

We can and should all make a contribution to the good things in our local area

Picking up rubbish in public places

In the Mandurah area

Controlling fleabane and other weeds, Mandurah

Peel Estuary and Mandurah - Observations

Mandurah volunteers, a page to try to connect them

Bicycling in Mandurah; some comments on enjoyable places to go on your bike.

Further afield in WA

Images of WA, from a visitor

Images of WA, from a new resident