The disaster that is religion

People have always looked for explanations: Why does the Sun rise every day? What causes a plant to grow? Why do things fall down when you drop them.

And then there are moral questions: Is it ever right to kill someone else? How should people of different sexes relate to each other? How should we treat our neighbours? - strangers?

Religion has been one of humanity's oldest ways of explaining our world and of recording 'answers' to the moral questions. Other ways of finding explanations to the way the world works have been observation, reasoning and most recently and successfully, science; and in the case of the moral questions, philosophy is far to be preferred to religion.

Christianity, Islam and the world's other religions, in their many forms, are some of the Great Delusions that are crippling human society.


This page was started 2021/08/18
Contact: David K. Clarke – ©
 


What are the specific problems with religion?

 
Flying Spaghetti Monster
The Flying Spaghetti Monster is just as valid a God, just as imaginary a God, just as unprovable a God and just as ridiculous a God, as any other, including the God of the Jews, Christians and Muslims.

Similarly, Bertrand Russell proposed a china teapot in solar orbit between Earth and Mars; just as impossible to prove or disprove as is the existence of God.

  1. Religious people tend to believe that they have the only true religion and that everyone who disagrees with them must therefore be wrong. What possible justification could anyone have for assuming that their religion was right and all the other religions of the world were wrong?

  2. When a particular religion becomes dominant in an area the adherents of that religion tend to become intolerant of others and try to force them to conform. I have written on another page of the many groups that tried to break away from mainstream Christianity and were exterminated;

  3. Religious people tend to rely on 'holy books' for what they see as 'the truth', while there is absolutely no verifiable evidence supporting the validity of the claims in the 'holy books'.

    The people who wrote what is recorded in the 'holy books' seemed to have believed they somehow knew what God wanted, or that God talked to them. I have addressed the contradiction of God talking to them and not talking to all of us on another page on this site.

    Often, science has demonstrated the fallacy of the 'revealed truths', yet the religious prefer the delusion.

  4. Some at least of the 'holy books' contain contradictions, because different parts were written at very different times and under very different moral views;

  5. Almost all 'holy books' are interpreted differently by different people at different times and for different purposes;

  6. Religious people tend to rely on the moral rules of their 'holy books', while often ethics, moral philosophy, has shown that the moral laws of the 'holy books' are insupportable (for example stoning as punishment for adultery and other 'sins' - in both the Bible and Koran). But some of the religious adherents prefer the old rules even though they are often cruel and unjust;

  7. Religions are often 'set in stone', inflexible. Humanity has learned an enormous amount particularly over the past few hundred years, this valuable and verifiable knowledge tends to be ignored by the religious;

  8. Religion serves as a place for the religious to hide from reality ("The opium of the people"). At this time in world history, perhaps more than any other, we must all face up to reality, especially the huge problems that humanity's carelessness has caused to our shared planet. If we don't face up to our shared problems they will inundate us.

 

Greenhouse emissions

The burning of fossil fuels is widely recognised as the main cause of climate change, ocean acidification, sea level rise and ocean warming. The air pollution from the burning of fossil fuels kills millions of people world-wide each year.
At the time of writing, August 2021, there is one great threat facing our shared planet and a number of smaller, but still substantial threats. The great threat is climate change and its related problems.

The primary cause of climate change is not our abundant greenhouse gas emissions, that is the secondary cause. The primary cause is human overpopulation and selfishness. It is people, groups and governments putting their selfish interests first and the good of our shared planet later that is stopping us from seriously facing the challenges of our emissions.

Another big obvious and current threat is the COVID-19 pandemic. Then there are things like loss of forests, pollution of land, rivers, lakes and oceans by plastics and a great many chemicals, over fishing, desertification and more; I have written on another page on this site about our unsustainable civilisation.


Religion's threat to environmental progress

Sunrise over Peel Inlet

We share a wonderfully beautiful world, but we are damaging it through carelessness, selfishness and greed.

If humanity is to overcome the climate change and other threats we must have clear thinking: science, reason, not unfounded superstition.

The world needs people to be able to think clearly; they can’t if they are labouring under delusions, especially such huge, life-defining and life-dominating ones as religion.




 
 
Islam, peace and tolerance

Religion is too open to interpretation

Since the people who wrote the religious texts are no longer available for us to ask them exactly what they meant, we have to rely on interpreting their meaning from the 'holy books'.

Plainly different people in different times and places have hugely different interpretations of the meanings of the ancient writings.

As an example, the pamphlet on the right was placed in my letterbox a day or two before the aggressive, murderous, cruel, barbaric, intolerant and strongly Islamic Taliban took over the Afghan capital Cabul in August 2021. Obviously the Taliban's interpretation of Islam is anything but peaceful and tolerant.

I have placed this image and comment here, not because I believe Muslims to be bad people; the great majority of Muslim people around the world are decent, peaceful and tolerant. But the Taliban, and for that matter ISIS, have a totally different interpretation of Islam.

Christianity too

Islam is far from the only religion that has been twisted into something cruel; many people in past centuries were tortured and burned at the stake by 'Christians'. On and off for a century or so Catholic 'Christians' killed Protestant 'Christians' and vice-versa at the time of the Reformation; both lots claimed to be followers of Jesus who preached kindness, forgiveness and 'turning the other cheek'.

I have written on Christian intolerance on another page on this site.

My whole point, the point of this page, is that religion is capable of corrupting anyone who is taken in by it.

Damaging God's creation

Two Australian prime ministers, Tony Abbott and Scott Morrison both professed to be devout Christians, yet they saw nothing wrong with doing their best to destroy what they must have seen to be their God's creation by advocating the burning of more and more fossil fuels and resisting the change over to renewable energy.

North Blinman, South Australia, on a misty morning
Blinman
Just one little part of what a religion person would consider to be God's beautiful creation



Established religions become corrupt, intolerant and cruel

 

Religion (and other delusions) cause good people to do bad things

"Good people will do good things, and bad people will do bad things. But for good people to do bad things – that takes religion."
Steven Weinberg, Nobel laureate

I have to slightly disagree with Steven Weinberg on this point, I would replace 'religion' with 'delusion'. The required delusion can be religion, but other delusions will also serve the purpose. For example, a well-meaning person ran a campaign trying to link wind turbines with bad health from about 2010 to 2014 in Australia; but, of course, the link existed only in the imagination of a number of gullible people.

Several of the greatest of the social systems that grew around religions came to be intolerant, self-centred and tyrannical. That seems to be a tendency for any social system, religious or secular, that comes to dominate a region, nation or community. Those in charge seek to gain more and more power over the powerless majority, simply because they can.

I'm thinking here particularly of the Christianity adopted as the official religion of the Roman Empire by Emperor Theodosius around 390AD and Islam (both Shia and Sunni Islam seem to date from around the death of Mohamed, 632 CE).

The Christian establishment in Europe held back free thought, clear thinking in ethics and scientific advance for much of the period from the fall of the Roman Empire to the Renaissance and beyond. The delusion that is religion is still stopping the majority of humans from access to fully rational thought.

I have summarised elsewhere how much there is in the Christian 'holy books' that were shockingly unethical by any reasonable standards elsewhere in these pages. What the Christian call the Old Testament was based primarily on the 24 books of the Hebrew Bible or Tanakh. It is also holy to the Muslims. I have written on the horrors that the Bible records as being done by 'holy' people elsewhere in this pages.


One good point in favour of religion

In the community scale religion provides social connection. People connect to others in the same religious group, Catholics feel close to other Catholics, Lutherans feel close to other Lutherans, members of the Uniting Church feel close to other members, Shia Muslims feel close to other Shia Muslims, Buddhists feel close to other Buddhists and Hindus feel close to other Hindus.

But even this has its downside. Just like with ex Australian Prime Minister John Howard's mateship, those outside the in-group are treated with less consideration than those inside.

Outside of religions there are many service groups that can also provide social connection: Apex, Lions, Rotary, Soroptimist, Country Women's Association, Zonta...   SA Community lists hundreds of such groups within just my home state, South Australia.






Related pages

Related pages on this site...

A list of my pages on superstition and religion are on my home page

Pages having particular relevance to the subject of this page are...
The concept of an immortal soul is logically unsupportable
The Bible
Christian 'virtues and values'
Delusions
Islam's threat to freedom and a rational society
Religion and other superstitions
The absurdity of religion
Why doesn't God talk to us

Another point of view...

A rational 'religion'
My 'religion'